Abstract: OBJECTIVES: to measure whether people aged 65 and over living in Britain would be willing to give up their place on the cardiac surgery waiting list for someone younger than them. METHODS: two British surveys, based on random types of people sampled for the Office for National Statistics Omnibus Surveys, identified respondents aged 65 and over for a module on waiting lists. They were asked to imagine they had a heart condition that required surgery, and that they were on an NHS waiting list. They were then asked if they would be prepared to give up their place on the cardiac surgery waiting list to a younger person (aged 45). The study compared responses to one of two relative waiting list time frames (6 and 12 months). SETTING: two national random samples of the British public aged 65 and over. RESULTS: fifty eight per cent and 62% of Omnibus respondents aged 65 and over responded that it was not right to give up their place on the cardiac surgery waiting list for someone younger in relation to a 6 and 12 month wait respectively. Thirty seven per cent and 34% of each group of Omnibus respondents aged 65+ said it was right to give up their place on the cardiac surgery waiting list for someone younger than them, in relation to a 6 and 12 month relative waiting period respectively. Thus the length of the wait had little effect on response among British respondents. The proportions who were willing to cede priority are far less than that reported in a comparable Italian survey. Consistent with the Italian survey, willingness to cede priority increased with age. CONCLUSIONS: most older people in Britain do not wish to cede priority on the waiting list for cardiac surgery to people younger than themselves, although willingness to give up one's place increased with age. The specific time frame did not have an impact on people's responses. The increase in willingness to cede priority with older age could be interpreted as older people valuing themselves less, or that they feel that they have had their 'fair innings' and are willing to give younger people the chance of reaching their age. It could even reflect a cohort effect. It is likely that ageing 'baby boomers' may be even less willing to give up their place in the health service queue and will be more assertive about their right to equity in health care provision.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Fair management of queues for hospital-based services requires consideration of clinical need, but there is no information on public attitudes towards non-clinical factors such as age or work status as determinants of priority. METHODS: We asked elderly residents of Padova, Italy, whether, if they were awaiting cardiac surgery or an outpatient cardiology consultant, they would give up their place in line for a younger or self-employed individual. We also elicited responses from a convenience sample of younger health workers asked to imagine themselves as elderly persons facing the same choices. FINDINGS: The eligible response rate was 72% (443/616). About half deemed it right to give up their place in line for cardiac surgery to a 45-year-old (51%, 95% CI 46-56) or self-employed person (47%, 95% CI 42-51) Proportions were significantly higher for an outpatient consultation (68%, 95% CI 63-72). In multivariate analyses, married respondents, those closer to age 65, university graduates, and those who were formerly self-employed were significantly less likely to respond affirmatively. In significant contrast for all four scenarios (p<0.0001), the overwhelming majority of non-elderly respondents refused to give up their places in line. INTERPRETATION: The majority of elderly citizens were hypothetically willing to cede priority in accessing cardiac care to younger or self-employed persons, but this willingness was attenuated among the "young" elderly and more privileged respondents. Non-elderly respondents were much less self-sacrificing, suggesting that ageing baby-boomers may be more assertive about their continuing rights to health care.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To examine the distribution of interventional cardiac catheterization laboratories, their case load, the time trends, and the regional variation of percutaneous transluminal cutaneous angioplasty (PTCA) utilization in Italy. METHODS: Analysis of data was provided by the annual reports of the Italian Group of Studies and Interventional Cardiology over the period from 1983 to 1996. RESULTS: The number of PTCA facilities and their use steadily increased, mainly in the North. In 1996 the utilization rate was 34 per 100,000 population, but only 60% of labs performed 200 or more procedures. CONCLUSIONS: Dramatic time trends and regional variations often took place without an epidemiology and technology assessment-based planning process.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Coronary angiography is an invasive procedure that is relatively expensive and that requires an appropriate indication. METHODS: Utilization rate and the appropriateness of the use of the coronary angiography have been compared in two defined populations, namely residents from the city of Padua (group A), and subjects from the local health unit of Cittadella (group B), who underwent coronary angiography between June 1, 1992 and May 31, 1993. Appropriateness was evaluated both by comparison with the AHA/ACC guidelines and by observation of the outcome following diagnosis one year after the coronary angiogram was performed. RESULTS: One hundred and seventy-one patients in group A and 100 patients in group B underwent coronary angiography: both groups had similar age and sex distribution. Utilization rate was 8 per 10,000 inhabitants in group A, and 10 per 10,000 inhabitants in group B. Appropriate coronary angiography, evaluated by comparison with the AHA/ACC guidelines, was 69.9% in group A and 68% in group B. Coronary angiogram showed at least one stenosis > or = 50% in 133 patients from group A and in 66 patients from group B. These patients were followed up for at least 12 months. Of 13 deaths, 12 occurred as fatal cardiac events, while of the 147 surviving patients who had complete follow-up data, 114 (77%) improved. The outcome was measured through symptoms and stress test. In addition, subjective improvement was measured in group A using the "Nottingham Health Profile". CONCLUSIONS: Criteria of appropriateness for an invasive diagnostic procedure such as coronary angiography, which is a determinant "entry point" for revascularization procedures, is based on common clinical knowledge that may be evolving with time. Based on these data, it seems that the current guidelines could be modified, especially for indications within the setting of myocardial infarction.
Abstract: The use of cardiac catheterization procedures and the number of hemodynamic laboratories in Italy increased steadily from 1983 through 1993, sometimes with no planning or modern technology assessment. It is recommended that in the future funds be assigned to improve underused laboratories rather than to build new facilities.
Abstract: BACKGROUND. The diffusion of cardiac catheterization laboratories in Italy has been increasing in the last decade, often without a rational planning process evaluating costs, safety, concentration and case loads. METHODS. Data have been provided by the 1990 annual report of the Italian Group of Hemodynamic Studies and Interventional Cardiology which includes, following the best estimates, about 90% of public and private labs. These data include all cardiac catheterization visits. In analysis, PTCA's have been separately considered. RESULTS. In 1990, 85 laboratories with 101 rooms were active. The distribution of the labs was 58% in the north, 14% in the middle and 28% in the south of the country. The number of labs per million inhabitants was 1.9, 1.1 and 1.2 respectively, with a national average of 1.5. The percentage of labs performing fewer than 300 visits per year was 33% in the country. Within the areas, such percentages were 33%, 17% and 42% respectively. A total of 48,518 exams were performed (61%, 18% and 21% in the three areas) with a rate per 100,000 of 115, 82 and 51 (national rate 86). 5,145 PTCA's were carried out in the same year, about 80% of which were in the north area. CONCLUSIONS. Even if data could be underestimated, a great difference in geographical distribution of labs was confirmed. This might be explained by morbidity, population age and mobility of patients across the country. The percentage of labs performing fewer than 300 studies is relevant, in particular in the south and in the Isles. Planning for future requirements should include the amelioration of utilization rates (in a perspective of cost containment and patient safety), a thorough evaluation of demographic and morbidity trends, and an estimate of the proportion of inappropriate procedures.
Abstract: In recent years there has been a steady increase in number of coronary angiography procedures and coronary angioplasty. Since these interventions are relatively expensive, we tried to evaluate the appropriateness of coronary angiography indications. A retrospective pilot study was undertaken on all residents in Padua who had had a coronary angiography performed in 1988. In order to take into account patients who, although resident in Padua, had a coronary angiography performed outside Padua or even abroad, all Italian Hemodynamic Centers and the Office for Foreign Cures Authorization of ULSS 21 were contacted. Follow-up was stopped on April, 1991. Patients were first checked if living by consulting the Register's Office of the Community of Padua; they were then interviewed by letter on state of health. One hundred twenty-four patients underwent 138 coronary angiography. Utilization rate is 5.6 per 10,000 people (CI 4.6-6.6). This figure is lower than the present USA utilization rate, and is similar to the rate of late 70's. From patient records, 3 out 8 groups emerged as predominant indication for coronary angiography: unstable angina (37%), valvular heart disease (20%) and recent myocardial infarction (20%). According the ACC/AHA guidelines, indication was considered "appropriate" in 69%, "inappropriate" in 7%, "doubtful" in 20% and impossible to evaluate in 5% of cases. Although this classification may have been built up with incomplete information, it is note-worthy that the percentage of inappropriate indication is comparable to that of other reports. A further observation is that not in every case the treatment assigned at the time of diagnostic angiography was really carried out on the patients.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
Abstract: A quality improvement system has been established in 1989 in the hospital network of Padua and its organization is described. Three selected experiences are reported. (1) Appropriateness of the use of human albumin. After the assessment of the clinical policy, new guidelines were experimentally introduced and an evaluation after 3 months has shown a decrease of the total number of prescriptions (25%) and of inappropriate indications (9% vs 40.1%). (2) Urinary Tract Infections (UTI) and indwelling catheterization. The study showed 49% of conditions related to UTI and some corrigible inadequacies in the process of care: 37.2% of indications were probably not justified; 40% of patients who did not undergo urineculture had indications and 13% who underwent urineculture had no indications to the test. Guidelines for appropriate indications and a continuing education programme have been introduced. (3) Falls by hospitalized patients. The patient fall rate was 0.3/1000. As the reporting system showed inaccuracies (for example, the severity of injury was not collected in 34% of cases), a new notification form was introduced in 1991.
