Abstract: ABSTRACT: BACKGROUND: Two case studies are presented to examine how cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) of auditory hallucinations can be fitted to mild and moderate intellectual disability. METHODS: A 38-year-old female patient with mild intellectual disability and a 44-year-old male patient with moderate intellectual disability, both suffering from persistent auditory hallucinations, were treated with CBT. Patients were assessed on beliefs about their voices and their inappropriate coping behaviour to them. The traditional CBT techniques were modified to reduce the emphasis placed on cognitive abilities. Verbal strategies were replaced by more concrete tasks using roleplaying, figurines and touch and feel experimentation. RESULTS: Both patients improved on selected variables. They both gradually managed to reduce the power they attributed to the voice after the introduction of the therapy, and maintained their progress at follow-up. Their inappropriate behaviour consecutive to the belief about voices diminished in both cases. CONCLUSION: These two case studies illustrate the feasibility of CBT for psychotic symptoms with intellectually disabled people, but need to be confirmed by more stringent studies.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: "Michael's game" is a card game which aims at familiarizing healthcare professionals and patients with cognitive behavioral therapy of psychotic symptoms. This naturalistic study tests the feasibility and the impact of the intervention in various naturalistic settings. METHOD: Fifty five patients were recruited in seven centers. They were assessed in pre and post-test with the Peters Delusion Inventory--21 items (PDI-21). RESULTS: Forty five patients completed the intervention significantly reducing their conviction and preoccupation scores on the PDI-21. CONCLUSION: This pilot study supports the feasibility and effectiveness of "Michael's game" in naturalistic setting. Additional studies could validate the game in a controlled fashion.
Abstract: Several studies have shown that source-monitoring errors are related to verbal hallucinations in schizophrenia. An exploratory pilot study has been carried out to investigate the possibility of training patients in how to avoid errors in source-monitoring. One patient with paranoid schizophrenia and persistent thought insertions was trained for 6 hours to use mnemonic techniques to compensate specific deficits in source-monitoring. Results show that the patient was able to improve his performance and maintain the acquired progress at a 1-month follow-up assessment. These preliminary results are interesting for developing a larger controlled study of cognitive remediation of source-monitoring deficits.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Despite the effectiveness of anti-psychotic pharmacotherapy, residual hallucinations and delusions do not completely resolve in some medicated patients. Additional cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) seems to improve the management of positive symptoms. Despite promising results, the efficacy of CBT is still unclear. The present study addresses this issue taking into account a number of newly published controlled studies. METHOD: Fourteen studies including 1484 patients, published between 1990 and 2004 were identified and a meta-analysis of their results performed. RESULTS: Compared to other adjunctive measures, CBT showed significant reduction in positive symptoms and there was a higher benefit of CBT for patients suffering an acute psychotic episode versus the chronic condition (effect size of 0.57 vs. 0.27). DISCUSSION: CBT is a promising adjunctive treatment for positive symptoms in schizophrenia spectrum disorders. However, a number of potentially modifying variables have not yet been examined, such as therapeutic alliance and neuropsychological deficits.
Abstract: The psychotic experience is often seen as qualitatively different from normality. Empirical data show that psychotic symptoms have to be described on a continuum between normality and psychosis. A model of construction of delusional ideas starting from making sense of perceptual aberrations integrating reasoning styles, personal and cultural variables is presented. This model also show how delusional ideas are maintained through bias of selection and behaviors associated with delusional ideas which are naturally reinforced in natural environments. Cognitive-Behavior Therapy (CBT) for psychotic symptoms is a validated psychological set of techniques useful to treat persistent psychotic symptoms. CBT is presented as a five steps intervention including: engagement and assessment, education and normalization of psychotic symptoms, verbal questioning of evidences supporting the beliefs, reality testing and consolidation.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: This study measures the impact of beliefs about auditory hallucinations on social functioning. SAMPLING AND METHODS: Twenty-nine subjects who met the ICD-10 criteria for schizophrenia or a schizo-affective disorder were included. Beliefs about voices and coping responses as measured by the Beliefs about Voices Questionnaire were compared with social functioning as assessed with the Life Skills Profile (LSP). RESULTS: The belief that voices are benevolent was associated with poor communication. Engagement with voices was correlated with the non-turbulence and the compliance factors of the LSP. Patients who held the belief that their voices were benevolent functioned significantly more poorly on the communication factor of the LSP than patients who interpreted their voices as malevolent. DISCUSSION: The results indicate that a positive relationship with voices may affect social functioning. However, the size of the sample is small and patients with benevolent voices are overrepresented. Nonetheless, these results have implications for the use of cognitive therapy for psychotic symptoms.
Abstract: INTRODUCTION: Since the discovery of neuroleptics and the reintegration of people with schizophrenia in the community, psycho-social reeducation became an essential part of the treatment. The Life Skills Profile is a tool of reference for assessment of the dimensions, which have an impact on the adaptation in community. Each item describes an observable behavior, written in common language, to allow the care-givers and the family to evaluate it without having a specific formation. The long version (39 items) is recommended for therapeutic interventions with a person and the short one (20 items) for large scale studies on outcome in community. AIM OF THE STUDY: In order to dispose of a measure of function and disability in schizophrenia, we have translated the Life Skills Profile (LSP) in French and tested the validity of this translation for the long version (39 items) and the short ones (16 and 20 items). The 4 dimensions of the 16-items version--"withdrawal", "self-care", "compliance" and "antisocial"--were used for people with mental disorders and the 20-items version enhanced with a fifth dimension "bizarre", especially useful for people with schizophrenia. METHOD: 175 people suffering of schizophrenia (DSM IV, codes F20.0 to F20.5) were evaluated by their caregivers in 3 settings: psychiatric hospital, ambulatory care and sheltered homes. Confirmatory factorial analyses were performed to test the dimensional models and their psychometric characteristics were established. RESULTS: The original structure in 5 dimensions of the long version (39 items) is not confirmed. However, the short versions in 16 and 20 items were confirmed, without any modification. The required psychometric qualities of reliability and validity of the 20-items version were fulfilled. The inter-rater reliability ranged from 0.65 to 0.75 for the 5 dimensions; the test-retest reliability ranged from 0.80 to 0.91 and the internal consistency from 0.67 to 0.81. The validity was evaluated by comparison of the LSP scores upon living arrangements (people living in sheltered homes had lesser scores) and pathologies (19 people with severe major depression had higher scores). CONCLUSION: The 39-items version of the Life Skills Profile was not validated in French. However, for clinical practice of social rehabilitation, this tool remains useful for a single person to check specific behaviors, which could hinder his/her integration into the community, to plan specific interventions and to evaluate changes, in addition with other scales. By the validation of the short version of the Life Skills Profile, an instrument is at disposal in French for outcome studies which allow to: 1) quickly assess the social functioning of person suffering of schizophrenia by a caregiver or a family member; 2) to detect insufficient skills in specific domains; and 3) to evaluate therapeutic efficiency.
Abstract: The aim of this study is to test the feasibility and the efficacy of a cognitive and behavior therapy manual for auditory hallucinations with persons suffering from schizophrenia in a French-speaking environment and under natural clinical conditions. Eight patients met ICD-10 criteria for paranoid schizophrenia, 2 for hebephrenic schizophrenia and 1 for schizoaffective disorder. All were hearing voices daily. Patients followed the intervention for 3 to 6 months according to their individual rhythms. Participants filled up questionnaires at pre-test, post-test and three months follow-up. The instruments were the Belief About Voice Questionnaire--Revised and two seven points scales about frequency of hallucinations and attribution of the source of the voices. Results show a decrease of voices' frequency and improvement in attributing the voices rather to an internal than to an external source. Malevolent or benevolent beliefs about voices are significantly decreased at follow-up as well as efforts at coping with hallucinations. Results should be interpreted with caution because of the small number of subjects. The sample may not be representative of patients with persistent symptoms since there is an over representation of patients with benevolent voices and an under representation of patients with substance misuse.
Abstract: During the past 20 years, therapeutic and rehabilitative modalities in the field of psychosocial rehabilitation have been diversified in becoming more specific. We have the possibility to offer individualized rehabilitation programs as well as in the general field of socio-professional goals as in the clinical field according to the patients' needs and personal assets. The content of these programs associates various forms of specialized medical and paramedical services. The indications are established trough a careful assessment. The rehabilitation unit of the University Department of Psychiatry in Lausanne has developed a multidisciplinary assessment method based on the bio-psychosocial integrative model and the vulnerability-stress model in integrating the level of experience of Wood for the analysis of the psychosocial functioning. This results in a structured assessment program, which leads to a multidisciplinary comprehensive assessment (difficulties versus adaptative resources).
Abstract: Outcome studies show that schizophrenia improves with the action of time. A minority of patients will be completely release from the illness. However the others will keep on suffering from the illness or its consequences. The aim of this paper is to put forward a psychological recovery model. The model is built from the experience of people who describe themselves as recovered from schizophrenia. Common elements of various patients' accounts and qualitative studies show that recovery is a step-by-step process. The recognition of these different steps should allow clinicians to provide more specifically psychosocial treatments validated to enable patients to go faster from one step to the other.
Abstract: This paper aims to assess current interventions in psychiatric rehabilitation in the French-speaking world and to discuss future developments. We review examples of policies and practices in Quebec and Europe and discuss the role and involvement of professionals; namely, the psychiatrists and the nursing staff. We also present different rehabilitation strategies and techniques used in the French-speaking world, such as case management, social-skills training, cognitive therapies for psychotic symptoms, family interventions, and return-to-work interventions. In conclusion, we invite psychiatrists to play a more active role in rehabilitation. We recommend the creation of small, specialized units closely linked to the needs of clients, and we propose to integrate social and medical interventions, rather than opposing them.
Abstract: This study describes a one year follow-up study of 53 ambulatory patients treated with case management oriented care. These patients, characterized by a chronic evolution for an average of 10 years, presented after a one year period a significant improvement of different symptomatic parameters (positive and negative psychotic symptoms). Psychosocial adaptation was also improved for their dependency, their activity and the amount of their social contacts. These results underline the usefulness of case management, which permits an optimal use of available therapeutic facilities. Moreover, the setting of such a program allows a more specifical treatment of this category of patients.
Abstract: Costs generated by chronically mentally ill are very high. Concerning direct costs (hospitalisations, outpatient services, medications), they are estimated from 120,000 to 160,000 french francs per year. Indirect costs (social security, gain lost) are assessed as being at least three times more than direct costs. Trimestrial costs, charged to insurance, of the first fourteen patients who followed the UCLA medication management module, have been retrospectively calculated on the base of the number of consultations, days at the hospital and community day center during the previous and following year of the introduction of the program. The intervention lasts 3 months with two weekly sessions of 1 h 30. The medication module aims the following goals: 1) Obtaining information about antipsychotic medication; 2) Knowing correct self-administration and evaluation of medication; 3) Identifying side effects of medication; and 4) Negotiating medication issues with health-care providers. The mean trimestrial costs curve goes down following the application of the program and this reduction continues 9 months after the end of the intervention. The small numbers of patients and the absence of control group do not allow to draw conclusions about these results. However, these data provide support to formulate an hypothesis about the effect of the module on medication compliance.
